Beyond Therapy v. Enhancement by Federica Lucivero, Anton Vedder

By Federica Lucivero, Anton Vedder

The controversy at the moral, social and criminal influence of applied sciences improving human functions has been mostly fed via philosophy and ethics students. those contributions supply arguments in favour or opposed to the use and distribution of roughly particular forms of improving applied sciences. considering that authors’ positions significantly differ from ‘trans-‘ or ‘post-‘ humanist claims in regards to the desirability of those applied sciences to ‘conservative’ perspectives against these applied sciences and exhibiting their hazards and perils, this debate is usually heated and burdened. the excellence among remedy and enhancement itself is exemplary during this admire. the excellence is frequently no longer intended to basically serve the theoretical goal of constructing definitional readability; it's also frequently implicitly used to depict one classification of activities as morally unproblematic (therapy) and one other type of activities as morally challenging (enhancement). the talk on human enhancement is not just a question of philosophical predicament however it is usually a scorching subject in public and political discussions, with an expanding call for of ecu associations for grounded suggestion relating regulations and governance of applied sciences for human enhancement. hence, at the one hand we have now a heated debate that may be a center curiosity of political associations and, nevertheless, we have now little mirrored image at the phrases and ideas of this debate. This quantity goals to fill this hole by means of supplying research and rationalization of the most developments, ideas, and assumptions of the talk. The essays during this quantity research the controversy from a meta-level, analysing the dialogue and mapping its arguments and conclusions, laying off new gentle at the conventional differences and assumptions within the debate on human enhancement from diversified disciplinary views: legislation, ethics, philosophy of know-how, technological know-how and expertise reviews, social sciences, engineering technology, expertise evaluate and basic law studies.

This quantity is without doubt one of the result of the venture Regulating rising applied sciences in Europe: Robotics dealing with legislations and Ethics (RoboLaw), funded below the seventh Framework Programme of the eu fee, and construction at the result of a workshop that happened in November 2012 on the Tilburg Institute for legislations, know-how, and Society of Tilburg collage, the Netherlands.

Show description

Read Online or Download Beyond Therapy v. Enhancement PDF

Best other social sciences books

Instantes y Azares - Especial "Maurice Blanchot. Materias de lo fragmentario"

Instantes y Azares - Escrituras Nietzscheanas, Año XII, nº eleven, primavera de 2012

Collected Papers VI. Literary Reality and Relationships

This booklet comprises texts committed by way of Alfred Schutz to the "normative" parts of literature and ethics. It comprises writings facing the author-reader courting, a number of realities, the literary province of which means, and Schutz's perspectives on equality. by no means released in English commentaries on Goethe's novel and the account of character within the social global seem during this quantity.

Extra resources for Beyond Therapy v. Enhancement

Example text

5 below). 67 Wolpe, n. 28 above, 388, 392. R. J. M. Regan, ‘Emergency Response Systems and the Creeping Legibility of People and Places’, (2004) 20 The Information Society 357-369, 362. J. Koops, ‘The Concept of Function Creep’ (forthcoming). , n 2 above. 68 This is most visible in Wolpe, who interlaces function-creep metaphors with a slippery-slope vision of the apparent inevitability of moving towards an (over)enthusiastic embracement of enhancement. Although he seems careful to phrase his argument in apparently neutral terms, his rhetorical questions on medicalisation carry a distinct undertone of disapproval: Is the typical, occasional erectile dysfunction that most men experience a ‘disease’ (or at least a condition worthy of medical attention) now that we have a treatment for it?

Extending these methods beyond the victims of trauma, to anyone who wishes to avoid remembering an unpleasant event, is another way in which the neural bases of memory could be altered to enhance normal function. T. J. , ‘Towards responsible use of cognitiveenhancing drugs by the healthy’, (2008) 456 Nature 702-705, 702. 61 N. Levy, ‘Neuroethics: Ethics and the Sciences of the Mind’, (2009) 4 Philosophy Compass 69-81, 70-72. 62 Echarte Alonso, n 17 above, 227 (my translation, BJK). , n 2 above.

There are other areas of neuroscience that raise additional ethical issues. 34 Thus, through this frame, the therapy/enhancement distinction is primarily a question of belonging to different territories. Each territory has its own jurisdiction, sovereign, rules, customs, and culture. The advent of psychopharmaceuticals raises questions because it is not an obvious resident of one or the other country. Hence, the map of the territories of medicine and enhancement becomes difficult to draw. The line marking the boundary is very ‘thin’ – indicating that the territories (or at least the areas close to the border) are closely connected through a permeable boundary; or the boundary is ‘blurred’ or a ‘grey zone’ – indicating that in this middle region, it is unclear which rules govern; or the boundary is ‘shifting’ so that the map continuously has to be redrawn – indicating that one territory annexes what used to belong to the other territory.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.50 of 5 – based on 22 votes